Monday, February 18, 2008

THE TRUTH ABOUT THE WORD OF FAITH

I used to wonder why Shepherding reappeared in the Charismatic churches considering that the founders pretty much shut it down around 1990, and publicly repented. It didn't make sense why it not only lingered, but began thriving again. I have lately found out why it reappeared. It snuck in through the teachings of the Word of Faith, one of the most influential movements since the Azusa Street Revival of 1906. The Word of Faith may be influential, but it is also an apostasy, and carries Shepherding clinging to it like a leech.

I was a follower of the Word of Faith doctrine from 1990 until 2005. Even when I began to break with the Word of Faith over the extremes of the Prosperity Gospel, I still maintained connections with them. I was a licensed minister through a Word of Faith church from 2004 through 2007, and my wife worked for Kenneth Copeland Ministries from 2003 until late 2007. During that time, I noticed more and more spiritual abuse, things that reminded me of Shepherding. I began to wonder, “Is the Word of Faith in general, and Kenneth Copeland Ministries in particular, Shepherdist, or merely spiritually abusive, or am I nuts?”

Early this year (2008), I found out that I am not nuts!

In his book A Different Gospel, D.R. McConnell points out the origins of the Word of Faith. This is not a rant by a Fundamentalist preacher. This book began as McConnell's master's thesis when he was a student at Oral Roberts University. He is a Charismatic pastor, so this is an insider's look at something he finds disturbing.

McConnell says that today's Word of Faith preachers (Kenneth Copeland, John Avanzini, Creflo Dollar, etc.) base their doctrine on the works and teachings of Kenneth Hagin. We knew that.

McConnell then says that Hagin based (some say plagiarized) his doctrines on the works of E.W. Kenyon. We knew that, too.

But then McConnell drops a 2,000 megaton bombshell, ripping through my views of the Word of Faith like a lawnmower through Bermuda grass. He states that Kenyon based his teachings and beliefs on what he was taught in college, at the hands of teachers who were Gnostic and Christian Scientist.

Whoa! That makes the whole doctrine pretty much suspect from the beginning!

Kenyon attended the Emerson School of Oratory in 1892. There, he was under the influence of Charles Emerson, a Christian Scientist; R.W. Trine, a Gnostic who wrote one of the major books on New Thought; and M.J. Savage, a Unitarian whose church Kenyon attended.

Let's look at those beliefs and see how the Word of Faith dovetails into them.

Gnosticism is a complex system of beliefs hammered together from earlier ones. It has existed as far back as before the time of Christ and was a real problem to the Church as early as the time of John and Peter. To summarize Gnosticism, it believes that salvation is through knowledge of mysteries (gained through intuition), that all matter is evil and that only spirit is good (a belief called Dualism), that Jesus could not have been purely good because He was in a human body, that Jesus was a mere man, that God created lesser gods, and that only Gnostics, “people who knew,” were guaranteed salvation. They also believe that God could only be reached through gnosis, through the divine revelation of mysterious knowledge. Gnostics also believe that God is a hermaphrodite; half male, half female. Gnostics believed in a divine formula, that once understood, would destroy the power of evil.

Gnosticism's more modern offshoot, New Thought, states that Spirit is the ultimate reality, the true human self is divine, divinely attuned thought is a positive force for good, most disease is mental in origin, and that right thinking has a healing effect. While that may sound Biblical, it is actually a form of early Humanism, and was founded on pantheism, occultism, spiritualism, and the basics of Gnosticism.

Christian Science is founded on the teachings of Mary Baker Eddy. This system believes a lot of things that are Biblical, but some of the things that they believe that aren't include “mind over matter,” the idea that all things are spiritual and the material world is an illusion, and the denial of physical ailments. Please note that Christian Science is not Scientology.

Hmmm ... I see parallels already. Let's review some of them.

The Word of Faith believes:

-- Divine Revelation: well, I believe in it, too, but all divine revelation has to mesh perfectly with the Bible. Word of Faith preachers teach that they are the dispensers of this revelation, and imply that only they are capable of giving it. They will rely more on what "God told them" than on what was written in the Bible, despite their insistence that we, the congregation, must find three scripture verses to support what we want to do. This is not unlike the Gnostic belief in mysterious knowledge.

-- They put God in a box: Word of Faith preachers deny God's sovereignty and actually mock the concept. They make God a slave to "spiritual laws" that even He can't break. They teach that we can twist God's arm to get what we want, enabling us to write our own ticket with Him (Kenneth Hagin's term), or turn God into a vending machine (Richard Roberts' term). The concept of spiritual laws and the idea that God is at our beck and call is definitely Gnostic.

-- Jesus died spiritually: while the idea that Jesus went to Hell is as old as the Church, the Nicene and Apostles' Creeds do NOT say that Jesus died spiritually and had to be born again. If Jesus did die spiritually, then Jesus was a mere man, and not God incarnate. Again, this is a Gnostic belief -- that Jesus was a mere man.

-- Spiritual laws: Word of Faith is founded on the concept that there are spiritual laws in the Bible, that even God is bound to obey. These spiritual laws include things like reciprocity, sowing and reaping, the law of sin and death, the law of the tongue, etc. Once these laws are understood and worked with, then Satan has no more power over the Christian. That may be true, and I'm not saying that it is, but it sounds an awful lot like the Gnostic belief in divine formulas.

-- God is as much female as He is male: I don't know where they get this from Biblically, but more than one Word of Faith has said this. They also teach that Adam was both male and female at the same time, and God removed Adam's female half, not just a rib. If this were true, then the pronoun for God in the Bible would be either "it" or "s/he," not "he." A hermaphroditic view of God is pure Gnosticism.

-- Man is equal with Jesus and God: the idea that we are made in God's image is Biblical, but the Word of Faith teaching that we are little gods, or that we are made in God's class is not. Being equal with God is Gnostic at best, Lucifer's rant at worst.

-- Our words can change time, space and matter: this is known as "Name It and Claim It." Sure, our words can change attitudes and maybe our bodies, but not to the extent that we are the "prophets of our own lives." This is Christian Scientist "mind over matter," retooled for modern times.

-- Emphasis on Dominion over the Earth instead of forgiveness of sins and the need to love others: Most Word of Faith theology is rooted in having dominion over the Earth, and that Adam was the god of this planet. Do I have to go into that? Gnostics believed that they were gods.

-- The reality of sickness and sin is denied: The Word of Faith says that they do not deny sickness and sin, but deny sickness and sin's place in their bodies. It's the same thing. Christian Science denies sickness, often to the point of dying instead of taking medicine. Word of Faith preachers do the same thing, often mocking doctors and medicine, despite having them on their daily television shows.

-- Prayer is replaced by confession: Prayer connects us with God. Confession connects us with us. In other words, confession, whether it is what we desire or a Bible verse, is a Gnostic practice of mumbling chants and spells, replacing God with our own minds, because we have the knowledge it takes to save ourselves.

-- God can only be pleased by faith: This is based on a verse in Hebrews. The implication is that if we are not standing on three scriptures from the Bible, believing we receive, and holding God to the spiritual laws, then God is not pleased with us. This is very similar to the Gnostic concept that the only way to God is through gnosis (in this case, the only way to God is through the strict definition of faith that the preacher uses). This totally rules out the concept that the way to God is through Jesus Christ.

-- Dualism: The Word of Faith stresses that everything is spiritual, and that the physical is not important. They mock education and creatitivy and the five human senses. They hate sex (Kenneth Copeland said that we were supposed to speak our children into existence, Gloria Copeland said that sex was a product of the fall of Adam, and Benny Hinn said that women were originally supposed to give birth from their armpits). Despite their obsession with healing, they hate the human body, calling it an "earth suit." Dualism is a Gnostic belief. Sure, you find the same teaching in the works of St. Augustine, but remember, he was a Gnostic before becoming a Christian.

I should have seen all this from the beginning, but I didn't. I fell for the teaching that I could get rich quick and that I didn't have to be sick a day in my life. There is a sucker born every minute! The reason the Word of Faith fooled me, and millions of other Christians, is that there is a lot of Biblical truth in it. Much of what Word of Faith preachers teach is sound. But what they teach that is sound is nothing more than the truths found in the Pentecostal movement of 1906 and the Charismatic Renewal of 1967. It's the rest that's poisoned; the part that orginated with Kenyon, was modified by Hagin and has been perpetuated by Copeland.

Another reason the Word of Faith fooled me, and millions of others, is that the preachers are genuinely sincere Christians who love Jesus! Kenyon, Hagin, Copeland, Dollar and others have helped millions of people know Christ better. They really believe that what they preach is totally Biblical. Unfortunately, it isn't. Kenyon fought against the metaphysical religions of Christian Science and New Thought, denying their more obvious unbiblical teachings. Yet, he ended up embracing enough of these unbiblical teachings to turn the Word of Faith from what should have been a new branch of the Pentecostal/Charismatic movement into a genuine cult.

I know, I know ... there are Word of Faith apologetics that refute every one of these observations. The thing for me is this -- I was an insider and saw this firsthand. I saw the abuses, and the apostasies, and people running around chanting their mantras, and I had enough. McConnell's claims make sense to me. They explain what I saw. You have to decide for yourself.

This does not make the Word of Faith a heresy. Heresy is a rebellion against the doctrines of an established church. The Word of Faith is its own denomination, so it has nothing to rebel against. It is instead, an apostasy! An apostasy is nothing less than a rebellion against God Himself.

It gets worse.

There is a direct link between the Word of Faith and Shepherding.

Tricia Tillin, in her online testimony, shows this direct link. She lives in Great Britain, and was involved with KCM and the Word of Faith during the latter part of the 20th Century. In her blog, she writes that in 1985, she visited the UK headquarters for KCM and had a conversation with the worker there. During this conversation, Mrs. Tillin brought up how she was relieved that Kenneth Copeland was so opposed to Shepherding. Mrs. Tillin expected the worker to agree with her. Instead, Mrs. Tillin writes “She was evasive, would not condemn Shepherding doctrines, and then said that there had been a change of heart and the Copeland ministry would now be working more closely with the Shepherding leadership, and we should be praying for unity between them. This was devastating! Formerly they agreed Shepherding was in error, but now they'd changed their minds, and were going to work alongside each other!”

Then there is Stephen Parson's book Ungodly Fear. Parson writes that in 1985 (the same year that Mrs. Tillin visited the KCM headquarters in Great Britain), at a convention of the Network of Christian Ministries, Kenneth Copeland said the Word of Faith and the Shepherding doctrines ought to be merged.

So, two different sources identify that the Word of Faith and Shepherding married each other. This does, at least to me, explains what I saw during my tenure with KCM and the Word of Faith. If the Word of Faith was so far from the truth to begin with, then it's easy to understand how it could so easily embrace another apostasy like Shepherding.

And it also explains how Shepherding has made so many inroads into the Charismatic churches and ministries. Kenneth Copeland is a highly respected and influential teacher among many Charismatics. They are simply doing what they see his ministry and church do.

13 comments:

a seed sower said...

I want to encourage you brother, I believe the Lord more than likely has so much more He wants to share through you. You really should prayerfully consider blogging more often to encourage the brethren...no need to post this unless you want to.
Seed

GospelofChrist said...

Thank you for your blogg, this is importen to know about the "charismatics", because they even don`t know from where those proclamations,and fabrications are come! God Bless You! If you look at my blogg you can find some more information about the same!

Margaret said...

In the Feburary Issue of Christian Press (www.ChristianPress.com) they published an artical Freemasons, Christian or cult? There was an upcoming conference on the subject. Because so few people will warn Chistians about the Freemasons many join. If you look at how long they have been around and what they believe, you can see all of the false religions in what they are truly about. The reason I mention this is they also published a short list of "Famous Masons". Included in the list were Adolph Hitler, Al Gore, Bill Clinton, Oral Roberts, Robert Schuller, Joseph Smith, Billy Graham and Kenneth Copeland. Are you sure Kenneth Copeland really believes what he teaches?

oceanwaves said...

Hi, it's Feb 2010 and I recently found
your blog. A number of years ago I
started studying spiritual abuse and
this led me to shepherding, one of the
main aspects of most spiritual abuse.
I agree that shepherding has definitely
gotten into most of the wof groups, although it is also found in other
groups that are not wof. The idea
that a believer MUST be "under"
another leader(s) is the same belief
found in catholicism (hierarchical
structure and priesthood). It is a potent evil and error, one which seems
to be wildly popular even with
believers who do love Jesus. Apparantly Satan is using this error
in a strategic infiltration of the
church. I had read somewhere online
that KCM had made some alliances with
some of the former shepherding groups.
This could have been a sincere but
misguided attempt to reconcile or
fellowship....in any case, it is impt
that believers be able to recognize
untruth and manipulation, whatever the
intent or the person involved. Hope
you are still out there, God bless.
Oceanwaves

Carolyn said...

People, you better becareful what you say against these men of God. They speak the truth of God's word. I know because I have done the word as they have said and it has worked for me personally.

Charmaine Ashby said...

These articles are terrific and they give arms and legs to what I have been seeing, hearing and feeling for the past 10-15 years. My pastor went from a person who taught the sciptures line by line to a magician who performed cheap trips. I knew this quoting of scripture to get what you want was wrong but I was alone in my circle. An old charismatic preacher told me in 96 taht the was a strong concentration of shepherdhip error on te east coast. Thanks and let God continue to use use you. I don't have to imagine what you have gone to receive and share these truths because I have suffered also.

Truth Seeker said...

Carolyn,
Just because something works for you that these wof preachers espouse, does in no way shape or form make what they teach right before a Holy God. Nor does it mean that God has ordained and Blessed these apostate teachings. You, my dear, should be the one to stop defending your pet preachers and start defending the truth.

austin said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
austin said...

Hagin stole his doctrine from EW Kenyon and was sued for $20 million by Ruth Kenyon, his surviving daughter. Copeland and all the other "Faith" teachers mimicked Hagin and Copeland and seem to be tainted by the same brush of error.

False claims of miracles, money preaching, scandals and the fallout of those who have left and exposed this movement are proof enough that something is gravely wrong with "Faith" teaching.

Never mind the lavish lifestyles of the leaders, what about the fact that many of these leading lights who taught "faith and healing" (for money) have since died of cancer and other serious terminal illnesses - does that say something in itself to those who would follow in their footsteps???

Austin

lee woo said...

To be an atheist requires an indefinitely greater measure of faith than to recieve all the great truths which atheism would deny. See the link below for more info.


#truths
www.ufgop.org

Sam I Am said...

You should read Joe McIntyre's book on Kenyon. He refutes McConnell's claims about the metaphysical influence on Kenyon. The fact is E.W. Kenyon rejected the views of Christian Science, and argued against them. McConnell even admitted that in his book. The whole thing boils down to a guilt-by-association argument. The fact that Kenyon (who was after all an aspiring actor at the time) attended the Emerson School of Oratory for two semesters at a time when New Thought was rampant in New England doesn't mean that he embraced it any more than the idea that somebody living in San Francisco is gay, or that somebody living in Sedona, Arizona is into New Age. If he was teaching heresy why was he accepted as a Free Will Baptist minister in good standing for fifty years? It doesn't add up.

Also, Kenneth Hagin didn't take his theology from Kenyon. He had been in the ministry for 14 years and was well grounded in Pentecostal theology before he ever heard of Kenyon. I cover all of this on my blog Jew and Greek. These are just baseless attempts by anti-WoF people to smear reputations in the name of God.

Anderson Raymond said...

Hi Everyone,
I'm from United Kingdom London, City(GB).I met this spell caster called Dr IyaryI of driayaryi2012@hotmail.com online and so many other, but i decided to go with this particular spell caster and this is about 2 weeks ago.I needed the spell caster to reunite me and my lover because she started behaving strange and a day came she text me and told me she cannot continue with the relationship anymore, that she just want to be alone.But a close friend of hers shows the guy to me that she was now dating.So i contacted this spell caster because i was totally heart broken and i smoked and get drunk till i could not even notice if am standing or lying.This spell caster told me not to worry, he gave me hope that am to have her again just like old times, and i provided all the requirements, and in just 5 days, my ex lover called me crying over the phone asking for me to forgive her for her stupid act, and she swore with her mother grave to love me and never hurt me again.This was what the spell caster earlier told me and it came after he has done the spell and that same night, my lover came back to the house to me. I have never seen spell as powerful as this but now, am convinced that Dr IyaryI is the best ever, You can contact him through him email address: driayaryi2012@hotmail.com or driayaryi2012@hotmail.com or And also Reach him on WhatsApp Number: +2349057915709 Thanks Dr. Iyaryi

clay said...

Thats correct... if you study the word and pray in the spirit you will find Hagin... Moore and Hutton to name a few are teaching truth...