Monday, February 18, 2008


There is a difference between a truly Christlike church and a Shepherding church. If you are still confused about what makes a Shepherding church, let's go over the signs. If you see these in your church or the ministry that you are associated with, then you are involved in a Shepherding church and you should run for your very life! These signs are similar to the signs of a spiritually abusive church. They will be similar – all Shepherding churches are spiritually abusive, but not all spiritually abusive churches are Shepherding churches.

A few of these signs will surface in just about any church, so if you recognize one or two, don't worry. The best ministers are still human, and even Peter and Paul made mistakes and hurt people. But if you recognize a majority, then it's time to re-evaluate where that church stands in your life.

Signs of a Shepherding Church

1. It is common for there to be no accountability of leadership to the church body or to an ecclesiastical authority in some form of denominational body. This does not mean that all non-denominational, independent churches are Shepherding churches. It just seems that most Charismatic churches that are Shepherding churches are not accountable to any organization. And, as we will see later in this book, some major denominations are now practicing Shepherding techniques.

2. The congregation, however, is totally accountable to the leadership of the church.

3. Extreme emphasis is placed on the authority of the pastors and the elders. Jesus, the Holy Spirit and the Bible take a back seat to the authority of the leadership of the church.

4. Elders, deacons, associate pastors, cell group leaders, etc., are picked by the senior pastor, not by the congregation.

5. Emphasis on the full five-fold ministry, with an undue amount of attention given to the apostle and the prophet.

6. Leaders are untouchable. They remain aloof from the congregation. Attempts to get to know them or to question them are met with “Don't touch God's anointed!”

7. The prophetic gifts are used to manipulate the congregation. Doom will be prophesied over someone who does not fully submit to the authority of leadership.

8. Loyalty to the pastor and the church is stressed, at the expense of loyalty to the congregation member's family and to God.

9. Oaths and vows are enforced on the congregation. Some of these include oaths of loyalty to the pastor, a promise to submit to the direction of church leaders, and vows of chastity by single people.

10. Congregation members are told that the primary way to receive God's blessings and to be protected from the power of Satan is to submit to the authority of the pastor and other leaders.

11. There is great emphasis on proper behavior and “sin management.” The verse “avoid the appearance of evil” will be used repeatedly.

12. Cell groups are “accountability groups,”instead of Bible study or prayer groups. Cell groups are a great idea, but when they are used to control the congregation's behavior, instead of studying the Bible on a more intimate level, there is something wrong.

13. Undue emphasis is placed on the public image of the church and ministry.

14. Undue emphasis is placed on what is appropriate behavior by the congregation.

15. Leadership seems to spend more time telling the congregation what to do than in teaching the congregation how to be a witness for Jesus to a dying world.

16. Directions for proper behavior seem to be rather prying and intimate. The congregation is told that they must do these things to receive God's blessings, live a Christlike life and be good disciples of Jesus. These directions are not offered as suggestions, but as commands. These direction include, but are not limited to, being told what to wear, what to read, what movies or television shows to watch, what to eat and drink, who to date, who to marry, how to have sex with one's spouse, how many children to have, how to raise one's children, who one's friend will be, where one should live, what job one should have, how many hours per day to pray and read the Bible, and how much money to give to the church.

17. Teachings are guilt and works based, instead of grace and salvation based.

18. Church members do not have the right to vote on church decisions. Decisions are made by church leaders on behalf of the congregation. In many cases, church members have no idea how the church money is spent, even though it came out of their pockets. This will be called the New Testament model of the church.

19. Small children in Sunday school or nurseries are subjected to corporal punishment to “drive the rebellion from them,” and are told that they need to repent for something as trivial as pulling the toys out of the toybox without permission. This happens at ages as young as two years old, an age that most theologians recognize as being too young to understand the concepts of rebellion and repentance.

20. Rejection or questioning of the authority, doctrines or teachings of the church is dealt with through “discipline,” which may include public humiliation of the congregation member or being kicked out of the church. At the least, the congregation member who does the questioning is called rebellious, and quite possibly accused of witchcraft.

21. Leadership encourages (sometimes demands) that congregation members become their “armor bearers,” basing this concept on one little guy who appears once in the Bible – Jonathan's armor bearer in 1 Samuel 14. While Jonathan's armor bearer as also his friend and advisor, Shepherding church armor bearers are assigned menial tasks such as cleaning the pastors' toilets and carrying their jackets and Bibles. They are sometimes totally ignored by leadership, not being spoken to for years.

22. Members who leave the church without the formal consent and blessing of leadership are shunned, or publicly slandered.

23. Former church members display a form of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. They report not wanting to go to church ever again, have difficulty reading their Bibles, and say that any thought of doing either causes them to be nauseated. They may also have stories of having been stalked or threatened by church leaders after they left.

These are terrible things! They are more in keeping with a cult than any Christlike church. I feel such shame and horror at having to list them as signs of any church, yet they exist and are growing and consuming people like the Blob in a trailer park.


a seed sower said...

Once again thank you for your service to the Lord and the body of Christ brother.

The things you're sharing are of great need today, many are held captive to these deceptive forces.

I am sure what you are sharing is of great encouragement to those who want to come out, or have come out of these types of situations.

I pray for those who have been nearly destroyed but such church leaders.
Oh Lord open their eyes and teach them to come to YOU alone LORD JESUS. For YOU are our Shepherd and YOU are all we need LORD. OH and LORD, please help these people to find fellowship with those in your body who can be used to help encourge them. May they learn to grown in YOUR Love and YOUR Grace oh JESUS name Amen..God bless you young brother.

Unknown said...

Hi, thanks for reading. One of the things that stood out to me when you speak of WOF is the word "wolf". Hmmm, just a thought.

I wonder why there is confusion around this for so many people? It's man's interpretation of the bible. We really need to read the bible for ourselves.

I believe God does want us to be blessed and give us the desires of our hearts. With that said, He wants us to be content and happy with what we have too.

I have many needs met, and I have many "desires" unmet. I have people who have died on me, that I prayed for them to live. Yet I still believe in God's Supremecy.

God has the ultimate Word on everything, not on what I confess or want necessarily. God answers all of our prayers, "yes, no, wait, later, etc."

We should be praying "God's will be done", not "my will be done".
I believe some of the greatest men and women who ever lived on earth, like John the Babtist were not "rich", yet they have treasures in heaven. Do you know what I mean?

Some people who were "rich" in the bible are living in HELL for all eternity. The bible warns us.

One more thing, I have been led astray, horribly, by listening to "pastors" or "evangelists" who "knew better than me" and who told me what to do.

Unfortunately I followed what they told me and guess who suffered for it? Me.

Now, 20 years later I can see the truth. I can see that these people did not "know more than me" for what God wanted me to do in and with my life.

And because I obeyed them, I missed out on great opportunities from God Himself. I have forgiven these people and forgiven myself for listening.

Jesus is my Lord. The Holy Spirit lives in me and God is my Father. I can hear directly from God and I can read the bible for myself.

God bless everyone who reads this. May we all be led in truth by Jesus Christ the Son of God, through the Holy Spirit living in us as we read the bible for ourselves.

k8y said...

PTSD... I can totally relate. What's sad is that when I typed that first sentence I was actually thinking, "Should I not type that? What if it comes true because I typed it?" I also don't even want to read my Bible anymore. I know I must and will but am thoroughly enjoying my brain being out of the blender for the time being. I'm thinking therapy couldn't hurt! hahaha

briankarcher said...

Thank you for sharing this! I reposted on my blog:

Anderson Raymond said...

Hi Everyone,
I'm from United Kingdom London, City(GB).I met this spell caster called Dr IyaryI of online and so many other, but i decided to go with this particular spell caster and this is about 2 weeks ago.I needed the spell caster to reunite me and my lover because she started behaving strange and a day came she text me and told me she cannot continue with the relationship anymore, that she just want to be alone.But a close friend of hers shows the guy to me that she was now dating.So i contacted this spell caster because i was totally heart broken and i smoked and get drunk till i could not even notice if am standing or lying.This spell caster told me not to worry, he gave me hope that am to have her again just like old times, and i provided all the requirements, and in just 5 days, my ex lover called me crying over the phone asking for me to forgive her for her stupid act, and she swore with her mother grave to love me and never hurt me again.This was what the spell caster earlier told me and it came after he has done the spell and that same night, my lover came back to the house to me. I have never seen spell as powerful as this but now, am convinced that Dr IyaryI is the best ever, You can contact him through him email address: or or And also Reach him on WhatsApp Number: +2349057915709 Thanks Dr. Iyaryi

Johnson Hatton said...

We have a direct genuine provider for BG/SBLC specifically for lease, at leasing price of 4+2 of face value, Issuance by HSBC London/Hong Kong or any other AA rated Bank in Europe, Middle East or USA.

Contact : Mr. Johnson Hatton
Skype ID: johnson.hatton007

Intermediaries/Consultants/Brokers are welcome to bring their clients and are 100% protected. In complete confidence, we will work together for the benefits of all parties involved.

All inquires to Mr. Johnson Hatton should include the following minimum information so I can quickly address your needs:

Complete contact information:
What exactly do you need?
How long do you need it for?
Are you a principal borrower or a broker?

Contact me for more details.

Johnson Hatton